Minga Indigena in Glasgow – about false solutions to the climate crisis

Nov 15, 2021 | Activism

Banner-Minga-Indigena-final.jpg

Minga Indigena – the Indigienous Way of knowledge and balance with nature

All through the 2 weeks of COP26 there were hundreds of meetings and workshops and debates, many “in person” and many also online.

Our small CICD delegation attended some different debates and presentations. We started with Minga Indigena. There is a large gathering of Indiginious elders and activists from the Americas at COP26, and we went to an event about “False solutions to the climate crisis – the disguise of Net Zero and carbon markets” where 5 speakers and 2 translators shared their experiences with the public and answered questions.

It was 1 ½ hours of very serious, touching and heartfelt testimonials and discussions. The meeting was calm and peaceful, but very intense and full of energy.

The 5 speakers spoke to an almost full auditorium about the power of life, and about how the traditions and way to survive in balance with nature that indigenious peoples have developed during thousands of years are disregarded….. at our peril.

Their land and knowledge are trampled on and not respected, often even in the name of development and sustainability. 

A Mexican woman gave a recent example, she spoke about how sustainable energy sources such as windmills and solar panels are established on indigeneous land in a way that completely overrides the lives and needs of the people living there. They had not been consulted on the project. Their need for electricity is very small, but still a huge complex is established on their land because of corporate interests….and then the price they end up having to pay for the electricity becomes so high that they cannot afford it.

The business interests and profit of private corporations are the priority and the opinions and needs of the indigeneous people are ignored. “Solutions” are imposed that in the end cause problems and harm. Carbon trading is trumpeted as one such solution – but that is a false solution if the biodiversity and forests are traded with on a carbon market and not saved!

A man from the Waorani people in Ecuador told about his people, that had only been in contact with “the rest of the world” since 1952. Only from 1980 they got the official “status” to their name. He gave an impassioned speech about the importance of not forgetting the old wisdom and losing the connection with nature, that his people had always survived with….and he told proudly about how they are now also using the internet, even in very remote areas, to access new learning and new ideas!

In Ecuador there are 3 million hectares of land that the indigeneous people are taking care of and protecting. They see themselves as the guardians of this land.

Ending deforestation by 2030 is not enough!

The pledge from the politicians at COP26 to end deforestation by 2030 does not take into account the situation of the many more areas that indigeneous people are taking care of. The destruction is allowed to continue.

Indigeneous peoples make up 6% of the worlds’ population but inhabit 85 % of the areas that are proposed for biodiversity conservation.

So clearly there should always be consultation and agreements with them regarding changes and projects on this land.

Litigation against big corporations

A Colombian barrister working in London explained about how litigation has won some big victories against big polluting companies – such as Shell in Netherlands recently – and she said it was very important that this continues. 

There are countries where international law regarding the environment is not recognised, like in the UK. To profit from this situatlon, Dutch Shell has now after loosing the above mentioned courtcase, changed its name and are moving its HQ to London.

 In other countries these international laws are recognised, but it’s not well known – such as many countries in Latin America. But she was hopeful about Chile. Here a new constitution is in the process of being written, and it will include protection of indigeneous people and the land.

Latest Blog Post

The Hidden Side of “Help”: Why We Need to Rethink Development

The Hidden Side of “Help”: Why We Need to Rethink Development

We usually don’t think twice when we hear the word “aid.” Most of us assume that helping someone is always a good thing—after all, how could giving to the poor be wrong? But I’ve realized that there is a big difference between just being “charitable” and actually doing development in a way that changes lives forever.

I used to think that poverty was just a lack of money, but the truth is often about a lack of
access. For a long time, the traditional “aid industry” followed theories that didn’t really work on the ground.
A powerful example of this is the story of Muhammad Yunus. He met a woman who had to borrow less than a dollar from a moneylender just to survive, but the terms were so bad she was basically a slave. He realized that by giving just $27 out of his own pocket, he could free 42 people from that cycle. This wasn’t just “giving money”; it was proving that the poor—especially women—are trustworthy and “credit-worthy,” even without any collateral.
Another thing I never really considered is that real help doesn’t always need a big institution. In many places, people are creating their own “financial inclusion” without any banks. For example, in Mali, women form small groups to save their own money and lend it to each other. It only costs about $20 to train a member, and then the group can run itself for years.

This is so much better than just a “handout” because it builds social capital—the women gain confidence, learn to lead, and even start their own businesses.

Finally, we have to look at how governments help. In Brazil, a program called Bolsa Família has liftedd millions out of poverty, but it isn’t just a “free gift”. Families only get the support if they meet social requirements, like making sure their kids go to school and get vaccinated. This way, the help isn’t just a temporary fix; it’s an investment in the next generation.

The more I learned, the more I saw that the best kind of development is about empowering people to be their own driving force for change. It’s about building their capacities, so they don’t need “aid” anymore.

My Personal Turning Point I never used to think about the “aid industry” this way. I just thought help was help. But exploring these different models and seeing how much impact
“doing it right” can have has completely shifted my perspective. This is exactly why I wanted to create this article: to tell you about my favourite course and why it changed my mind. It was through these specific lessons that I truly understood how we can move beyond simple charity to real, sustainable change.

Thanks for reading, a. see you soon!

Clothes & shoes sales creating change in Zambia

Clothes & shoes sales creating change in Zambia

My name is Raquel Dávila, I am from Mexico and currently volunteering in Zambia as a Development Instructor (DI) with DAPP Zambia through CICD. When I first arrived in Zambia, I did not fully understand how much impact second-hand clothes can have in a community. Many...